Menu of Goofee G's in Crest Hill, Illinois, USA

Menu Overview

Nestled in Crest Hill, Illinois, Goofee G's is a fresh gem in the ice cream scene that offers a delightful range of homemade scoop ice creams and sundaes. Located at 2225 Plainfield Rd, this spot combines a laid-back atmosphere with a spacious patio and ample parking, making it a perfect destination for families and ice cream lovers alike.

The menu at Goofee G's shines in its simplicity and creativity. Their signature sundaes, such as the Turtle and the eponymous Goofee G's sundae, offer well-balanced sweetness with generous toppings that complement the creamy base. The Banana Split, priced at $6.89, stands out as a nostalgic treat, layered with rich banana ice cream, chocolate, and whipped cream. Not to be missed is their Butter Pecan and Birthday Cake flavored scoops—each flavor delivers a distinctive, indulgent experience with a smooth, homemade texture that speaks to quality.

The Banana Ice Cream is a particular highlight, praised for its natural taste and creamy consistency, echoing customer Erin Traynor’s enthusiasm. The Bubble Gum Ice Cream adds a playful touch for those seeking something unique, while the Dark Chocolate variety satisfies any craving for deep, rich cocoa.

For those with dietary preferences, Goofee G's excels in offering dairy-free options such as Lemon Raspberry Italian Ice and Strawberry Sorbet, maintaining that silky smooth mouthfeel despite the absence of dairy—an impressive feat noted by customers like Rachael Romba.

The shake selection complements the scoops well, with the Goofee G’s Milkshake and Malts priced equally at $6.89 delivering thick, flavorful blends. The Root Beer Float, at $5.29, provides a nostalgic fizz that pairs well with the creaminess of the ice cream.

One of the defining features of Goofee G's is the homemade waffle cones, freshly crafted and crisp, enhancing every scoop or sundae. Service here is quick and friendly, contributing to a welcoming vibe that encourages repeat visits. The drive-thru option adds convenience without sacrificing quality.

While most reviews praise the relaxed ambiance, excellent flavors, and attentive service, some patrons have pointed out strict dish policies and occasional staff attitudes. However, these do not overshadow the overwhelmingly positive experience characterized by generous portions and fresh, handcrafted ingredients.

In summary, Goofee G's offers a compelling blend of classic and inventive ice cream options, a family-friendly setting, and dedicated craftsmanship. Whether craving a richly decadent Butter Pecan, a bright and fruity Italian Ice, or a classic Banana Split, this shop delivers both comfort and quality in every scoop. It’s poised to become a beloved staple in Crest Hill, inviting ice cream aficionados to savor every bite.